Seinfeld, Season Nine, Episode Sixteen, “The Burning”

Elaine discovers Puddy listens to Christian radio stations. George decides to try going out on a high note in meetings. Kramer and Mickey become med school actors. Jerry’s girlfriend is offended when he doesn’t automatically recognise her on the phone.

Written by: Jennifer Crittenden
Directed by: Andy Ackerman

Oh man. I don’t normally hold back on my insights here, even when I know a show will explore an idea more later, but I absolutely had to hold back on Puddy until now because this is the episode that fully clarifies what he is: the anti-George. It’s taken for granted by most Seinfeld fans that George is the true heart and soul of the show, to the point that people downplay the real life Seinfeld’s creative contributions to claim that Larry David (on whom George is based) is the true genius at the core. George is insecure, thoughtless, and reactive, constantly churning buckets of water out of a sinking ship that is his life, trying desperately to grasp onto anything that will give him the slightest bit of dignity. As the fictional Jerry pointed out, he’s not really the opposite of George – he’s the successful version of him, equally as neurotic and reactive in behaviour but a) able to hold down the one job for over a decade and b) taking more pleasure from life.

The show has been having fun with Puddy and his weird confidence since he showed up; Patrick Warburton tends to play his characters like they’ve got something else on their mind – something that comes off as intelligence in Brock Samson and innocent mind-wandering in Kronk – and that merges with the all-surface-detail writing of Seinfeld to make Puddy something almost alien. It’s with this episode that he becomes something more magical, as he reveals the two most anti-George traits possible: a rich inner life and a complete lack of need for reality to match up to it.

It’s remarkable for any comedy show to manage to keep evolving and building; Always Sunny is the diamond standard for this, going through various eras while still retaining a core identity, but Seinfeld managed it too, and Puddy feels like a late-stage character that develops out of the natural sense of humour, even more so than “increasingly bitter Elaine”. Indeed, the creatives recognised how Puddy was so funny because of how he irritates Elaine; we see here that she needs him to be as needy as her, and she doesn’t understand how someone can be comfortable with the world – an expansion of her outrage that he’s happy sitting with his own thoughts on a plane. I do also see how this is intertwined with her specifically hating the idea of being perceived; that someone, somewhere, might not see her the way she would like to see herself.

TOPICS O’ THE WEEK

  • “Don’t peel out.” / “I won’t.” [peels out]
  • “According the latest quarterly… thing… Kruger Industriual smoothing is heading into the red. Or the black. Or… whatever the bad one is!”
  • “Are you done?”
  • George’s plot of trying to go out on a high note is great, and I enjoy the turnabout of him having to deal with someone else being lazy. George being charismatic has given him more work.
  • “You think that Puddy actually believes in something?” Oh right, I forgot that she was also disturbed by the idea of someone actually believing in what they say, and what that implies about her as someone who doesn’t. “So you prefer dumb and lazy to religious?” / “Dumb and lazy, I understand.”
  • “How long have you two been together?” / “I dunno. Since the last one.”
  • “How did Puddy get back in the picture?” / “I, uh, needed to move a bureau.”
  • “I knew it was you, I was joking! I’m a comedian!”
  • “Sorry, buddy. This is the Hamlet of diseases.”
  • “And the Christian rock?” / “Resurrected.”
  • “I got him because he seemed so one dimensional! I feel misled!”
  • “She’s not a me. I’m a me.” / “I’m against all mes.”
  • “They? … The government?”
  • “Any other pain?” / “The haunting memories of lost love.”
  • The slow zoom on Kramer during his monologue is great.
  • Jerry on the phone with Sophie kills me. It’s kind of like the “My name is Mr Burns” scene on The Simpsons.
  • “Beep beep beep? What are you doing?” Perfectly captures a gag not landing.
  • “I’m not the one going to Hell.”
  • “Does she walk around holding a pen she doesn’t really need?”
  • “Why do I seek your counsel?”
  • “Well, I’m going to Hell.” / “Sounds about right.”
  • “Have you ever seen anything like this?” / “Never.”
  • “I gave you gonorrhea because I thought you’d have fun with it!”

Biggest Laugh: The look Jason Alexander gives to George whenever he registers that his joke has landed kills me every time.

Next Week: “The Bookstore”