Colour Outside the Lines #23: Scratching the Surface

Welcome to Colour Outside the Lines, The Avocado’s weekly discussion space for people of colour.

Thread Rules

  1. We ask that only those who identify as people of color participate in this discussion. White Avocados, while valued members of this community, should remain in ‘lurk’ mode.
  2. Shaming and hateful speech are unacceptable.
  3. Please keep potentially traumatic content safely behind spoiler tags.
  4. Nobody on this thread is more or less a person of color than anyone else. (We will not set clearly delineated boundaries on who qualifies as a ‘person of color.’ As a starting point, this thread uses the definition of ‘non-European heritage of sufficient prominence to affect one’s navigation of a society built on white normativity.’ However, we recognize that there are identities which skirt either side of the divide. If people feel that they meaningfully experience the identity of being a person of color, then they are welcome to participate.)
Additional Guidelines

1) The term ‘people of color’ encompasses a broad range of experiences. We are not a monolith. Therefore, we ask that participants respect each other’s experiences during the discussion, and refrain from promoting one particular experience as being more true to our shared identity as people of color. Furthermore, we ask that participants attempt to voice their own experiences as opposed to generalizing on behalf of the community as a whole. Of course, there are some exceptions. Participants are welcome to interrogate how shared experiences like marginalization help to forge common bonds within our community, but please remain courteous towards others in doing so.

2) We ask that participants remind mindful of the following: we would like to keep this space as safe from white privilege as possible. Even people of color can help to perpetuate systems of white privilege. For example, people who enjoy passing privilege may not understand the experience of being a visible minority. What people of one ethnicity know about people of another ethnicity might operate through the proxy of whiteness. We simply ask that a conscious effort is made to acknowledge white privilege. Likewise, we ask that visible minorities consider the unique challenges of passing privilege when posting. Again, we are only asking that participants keep this in mind while commenting.

[collapse]

The Prompt

This week, we’re going to have a bit of a more complex prompt that I usually put up, and I’m not wholly sure that I’m properly articulating the issue. But allow me to try.

In much of the developed English-speaking world, it’s generally acknowledged that racism is bad. As far as social norms go, this is a good one! Racism is bad. I mean, I hope no one reading this thinks racism is good; otherwise, what the hell are you doing here?

What this means is that white allies – or really any allies external to the groups in question – can be pretty good at identifying racism. However, they often don’t grasp its nuances. For them, racism is usually thought of as a rigid set of actions that could cause harm or offence to people of colour. They pattern-match current instances of it to past ones, often missing important or idiosyncratic context.

For instance, let’s look at an example from my hometown of Ottawa: the 2016 death of Abdirahman Abdi at the hands of a white police officer, Daniel Montsion. For observers outside of the city, this pattern-matched to the kinds of incidents of police brutality protested by Black Lives Matter in the United States. But people within the city could better recognize the incident as a culmination of a couple of decades of tension between the city’s Somali community and its mostly white majority (the group most commonly represented in the city’s law enforcement). Islamophobia and poverty played large roles in those tensions, and starting and ending the conversation at “Daniel Montsion is a racist” would miss a lot of important context, nuance, and history; it’s a true statement, but it really misses the broader picture.

So let’s talk about this: Is this a phenomenon you’ve observed before? How do you feel when well-meaning allies can identify an offence but don’t fully understand it? What’s the best way to educate people about this?

As always, the prompt is just a suggested discussion topic. If you’d like to discuss any other racial or ethnocultural issues, this is your safe space.

An Announcement

Due to popular demand, this thread will be moving to Wednesdays as of next week. Ardhanari will still be handling the last thread of every month.