The Day Thread Ranks Focus’s Albums: #14

#14: Focus con Proby (1978)

Imagine this. You’re the most successful band in the Netherlands. With several albums of sophisticated, mostly instrumental, progressive rock, you’ve broken through and established an international fan base and earned high praise from critics. But your last album, which turned toward shorter, lighter pop tunes, was not received very well, and your guitarist (who was also one half of your songwriting team) has just left the band. What do you do?

I don’t know how you, in particular, would answer that question, but I’m pretty confident your answer would not be, “I’d bring in washed-up American pop crooner P.J. Proby to sing a bunch of light jazz songs co-written by the remaining songwriter and his wife, over guitar noodling and generic funk beats.” Yet that baffling decision is the one made by composer/keyboardist/flautist Thijs van Leer and bassist Bert Ruiter.

Fortunately, Proby (best known to me as the guy the Beatles gave the song “That Means a Lot” to) only sings on five of the nine tracks; the other four are instrumentals. And there is some good playing on here; neither Eef Albers nor Philip Catherine were guitar wizards of the caliber of the departing Jan Akkerman, but they’re both more than competent. But the marriage of Proby’s vocal stylings with Focus’s jazz/prog sound simply doesn’t work and none of the compositions are anywhere near van Leer’s best. This is a bad album.

BEST SONG: “Sneezing Bull”

WORST SONGS: “Tokyo Rose”, “Maximum”, “How Long”

I didn’t mention that the drummer on this album, heard prominently here, is a pre-Journey Steve Smith.
This, I think, is actually a decent tune (though the beautiful introduction is a quote from Brahms), fortunately re-recorded later on Focus 8 as an instrumental.