Music, Open Threads

The Night Thread Ranks Paul McCartney’s Albums: #3

This is part of a series of mini-reviews of Paul McCartney’s studio albums, ranked worst to best. (Don’t worry; I’ll keep them short.)

Number Three: Chaos and Creation In The Backyard.

WHY IT’S CLASSIC: This was written and recorded when Paul’s second marriage was dissolving. It has a tone and quiet pain which reminds me of Pet Sounds. Co-producer Nigel Godrich gives it a contemporary and eerie feel.

BEST SONGS: Fine Line; Jenny Wren; At The Mercy; Too Much Rain; Riding To Vanity Fair; This Never Happened Before.

WORST SONGS: Follow Me is a bit weak, but that’s a nitpick.

WHY YOU SHOULD HEAR IT: It’s beautiful, and it will break your heart.

Paul wanted to do this fast and loud. Godrich convinced him to slow it down. Brilliant decision. Nigel’s reward was to never be invited to work with Paul again, which is what you get for challenging him. *sigh*