While people felt very comfortable with their choices in the Cake Final Eight, we had some angst over the pies. Which Thanksgiving treat would triumph? Which citrus pie had what it takes to emerge as champion? The hard choices were made, and so now we must bid a tearful good-bye to French Silk, Banana Cream, and Lemon Meringue.
The bracket’s toughest match-up brought multiple ties, until one brave soul finally broke it, sending crowd favorite Pumpkin to the locker room. We’re down to four. Upvote your pick in each match-up, and argue for your favorites. Good luck!