Well we made it through the nominations round; thank you to everyone who nominated and voted! As expected, the two-games-per-franchise rule kept out quite a few fan favorites, but worry not! If you’re mad that, say, Chocobo Racing is nowhere to be found, while, say, Platoon made it in with two measly votes (* tugs collar *), we’ll be having a mini-tournament at the end to determine which juggernaut franchise (Final Fantasy, Zelda, Star Wars, or Super Mario Bros.) offers the best in-world playable games overall.
So, for now, pour one out for:
- Cut by franchise limit: Chocobo Racing, Queen’s Blood, Totomostro, Riichi Mahjong, Motorcycle Sequence, Sphere Break, Battle Arena, Yeti Snowboarding, Bombchu Bowling, Claw Machine, Gerudo Archery, Tower Glide, Vehicle Test, Beetle Mania, Sabacc
- Lost the tiebreaker at 2 votes: Air Hockey, The Arcade, Farkle, Tableturf Battle, Dead Tetris, Fly
- Below the cutoff at 1 vote: Machine Strike, Darts/Billiards, Balatro, Baseball, Plants vs. Zombies, Tiger! Tiger!, Gradius, Home Run Contest, Roulette, Test, Cyberspace
- Disqualified: Credit Shooter, Taxi Driver, Fishing, Minigames, Computer Hack
And say howdy-do to our Round of 32!

Matchups are in the comments. Upvote your pick in each one!
Note: I tried my best to find gameplay videos without commentary but didn’t always succeed. If you have a better video than the one I found — or, worse, if I found the wrong game entirely — please post under Discussions and tag me (if it’s super egregious, I’ll swap out the video). Thanks!
REMINDERS
What Counted
A game the characters in the world sit down and play: Card games, dice games, board games, casino games, arcade cabinets, sports, etc. Tycoon counts. Queen’s Blood counts. Blitzball counts, whether you like it or not.
What Didn’t Count
Fishing, lockpicking, hacking, cooking, and anything else that is an activity and not a game. I love activity mini-games. They can have their own tournament. This is not that tournament.
The Rules
- Upvotes of top-level match participants determine what moves on to round 2.
- Please use the Discussion thread to argue for or against competitors or shoot the shit in general.
- Two entries per franchise, max, got in. At the end of the tournament we will have a separate mini-tournament (a game-inside-the-game, if you will) for the best overall franchise for in-world games.
Round One voting ends at 12pm CT on Tuesday, November 24.

You must be logged in to post a comment.